patrickjdempsey wrote:Aris wrote:Place old extensions.xml somewhere within your add-on/theme or on hdd and link to it.
Looks like the part of extensions.xml that actually does that work is <implementation> stuff which I do not think is allowed in a theme because it's JavaScript. It *might* pass review for SeaMonkey AMO but almost certainly not on Firefox AMO. It's going to require an extension to restore that on Firefox, and I haven't discussed this really with Philip or anyone, but once SeaMonkey is building again on Windows they might want to actually fix this. I know they like to do as little as possible with toolkit stuff since it's shared code but they might have to start doing their own thing with the addons manager.
Adding the untouched xml file from an older Fx version and leaving a comment to add-on reviewers what it is for and how it is used should be fine. It would be enough for me to grand full review, but I don't know how other (theme) reviewers think about it.